GlossaryDrainage technical term

Urine scale

Also: urinary scale, urine deposits, urine scale build-up

Urine scale is a rock-hard, yellowish-brown to grey deposit that forms wherever urine comes into contact with water and ceramics or a pipe wall: under the rim of the toilet bowl, in the urinal, in the trap and above all in the connection pipes and stacks behind them. What is visible in the bowl can often be removed yourself. What grows in the pipe only becomes apparent when the water stops draining away.

Karo job at a public toilet facility at a motorway service area, a typical place for urine scale in urinal and toilet pipes

In brief

Urine scale is a hard deposit made of minerals from urine and limescale from the flushing water. In the toilet bowl it can be dissolved with vinegar or citric acid and a little patience. If it sits in the urinal or toilet pipe, acid hardly helps: there it is removed mechanically with a milling head, chain flail or rotating high-pressure nozzle, and the result is checked with the camera.

What is urine scale?

Urine scale is a mineral deposit formed from components of urine and the limescale in the flushing water. It sticks firmly to ceramics, plastic and metal and gets a little thicker with every use. When fresh it is rather soft and porous, but after months and years it becomes as hard as stone – hence the name in German, «urine stone». Typical are yellowish, brownish or grey deposits with a rough surface that smell unpleasant because bacteria and urine residues become lodged in the pores.

In everyday life, urine scale is first noticed as an unsightly ring in the toilet bowl or as a coating in the urinal bowl. What matters for drainage, however, is what happens behind it: in the trap, the connection pipe and the soil stack, the same deposit builds up, only invisibly. There it narrows the cross-section until the water drains only slowly or stops altogether.

Technically, urine scale is a form of encrustation, that is, hard deposits adhering to the pipe wall. While the generic term encrustation also covers limescale from hot water, saponified fat or rust, urine scale refers exclusively to the deposit from urine and flushing water. It is therefore mainly an issue for toilet facilities, urinals and the pipes that drain them.

How does urine scale form?

Besides water, urine mainly contains urea as well as dissolved salts such as calcium, magnesium and phosphate. If urine is left standing or only thinly wets a surface, bacteria break down the urea into ammonia. This raises the pH value and the liquid becomes alkaline. In this alkaline environment, calcium and magnesium compounds can no longer remain in solution and precipitate as solid crystals, mainly as phosphates and carbonates.

The flushing water brings the second building block: limescale. In many regions of Switzerland, the tap water is hard, which means it contains a lot of dissolved calcium. This limescale is deposited together with the urine salts and makes the crust even harder. Paper fibres, hair and dirt are incorporated into the layers and give the deposit a hold. This is how a crust builds up layer by layer and adheres firmly to the wall.

Urine scale grows particularly quickly where there is little flushing. Urinals with economical flushing, waterless urinals, rarely used guest toilets or pipes with a shallow gradient are typical problem areas. Bends and transitions where the water flows more slowly and solids are left behind are also critical. The rougher a surface already is, the more easily the next layer adheres.

Removing urine scale in the toilet: what you can do at home

Urine scale in the visible toilet bowl or urinal bowl can in many cases be removed yourself. Because the deposit consists mainly of limescale and phosphate compounds, it dissolves with mild acids. Household vinegar, vinegar essence and citric acid have proved effective. The acid works best when it can act for a long time: first lower the water level in the bowl, apply the solution, leave it overnight and remove the dissolved deposit the next day with a brush or a plastic scraper. For stubborn rings, it helps to repeat the process several times.

Under the rim, which is hard to reach, kitchen paper soaked in vinegar or citric acid can keep the deposit moist for hours. Commercial toilet cleaners against urine scale work on the same principle, usually with stronger acids. Important: follow the instructions for use exactly, wear gloves, ventilate well and never mix acidic cleaners with chlorine-based products, because this can produce toxic chlorine gas.

Avoid steel wool, wire brushes and sharp blades, which scratch the glaze. Every scratch is a new rough spot to which urine scale later attaches all the more quickly. Concentrated hydrochloric acid or aggressive drain cleaners have no place in the home either: they attack seals, metal parts and older pipes and still do not solve the actual problem in the pipe.

The limits of home remedies are quickly reached once the urine scale is no longer in the bowl but in the trap or in the pipe. Acid poured into the bowl flows away with the next flush and reaches the crust further back only diluted and briefly. If the toilet drains slowly despite a clean bowl, gurgles or smells from the drain, the cause usually lies deeper.

Urine scale in the pipe: milling instead of acid

In connection pipes and soil stacks, urine scale often grows over years and can significantly narrow the cross-section. Normal jetting or a drain snake at most bores a hole through the crust: the water briefly flows again, but the cross-section remains narrow and the next blockage soon follows. Chemical products hardly work in the pipe, because they do not wet the thick layer for long enough, and they can attack pipes and seals.

Specialists therefore remove the crust mechanically. Depending on the pipe diameter and material, milling heads on the electromechanical pipe cleaning machine, chain flails with rotating chains or rotating high-pressure nozzles are used. The principle is similar to root cutting: the tool works its way through the deposit piece by piece until the pipe wall is clear again. The loosened chunks are then flushed out chemical-free at high pressure, at Karo with up to 200 bar.

It is crucial that the tool suits the pipe. Thin-walled plastic pipes, old cast iron pipes or fibre cement call for a different choice than a robust vitrified clay pipe. That is why a camera is part of the job: before milling, the CCTV drain survey shows how thick the crust is and where it sits; afterwards it confirms that the pipe is clear and that no damage was hidden under the deposit. The findings can be documented in accordance with SN EN 13508-2.

If you only tackle urine scale in the pipe with acid, you merely postpone the problem. The crust remains, the cross-section remains narrow, and acid residues can cause cast iron pipes to corrode. Mechanical descaling, on the other hand, removes the crust in a controlled way so that the pipe has its full cross-section again. After that, regular cleaning keeps any new deposit thin.

Urine scale in urinals and commercial premises

The most heavily affected properties are those with many users: restaurants and bars, school buildings, sports halls, office buildings, motorway service areas and public toilet facilities. Urinals there are used very frequently, but often only flushed a little to save water. The connection pipes of urinals are also comparatively narrow, so even a thin crust noticeably slows down drainage.

Several urinals are usually connected to a shared collector pipe that leads into the soil stack. If the crust grows there, the water first backs up in the lowest or last bowl in the row. Frequent consequences are standing water in the bowl, a smell of urine throughout the room and overflowing urinals – a problem that is immediately visible in a restaurant or a school.

Waterless urinals need particular attention. Because no flushing water follows, the urine in the pipe is hardly diluted, and urine scale forms particularly quickly. They need consistent care of the water seal trap and regular checks of the outlet pipe. For businesses, it is worth having urinal pipes cleaned at fixed intervals instead of waiting for the next blockage, because planned cleaning outside opening hours disrupts operations less than an emergency.

Urine scale or encrustation: the difference

The two terms are often used interchangeably, but they are not the same. Encrustation is the generic term for all hard deposits on the inner wall of a wastewater pipe, whether from limescale, fat, rust or urine. Urine scale is a particular form of it that only occurs in pipes through which urine flows. If your kitchen pipe is encrusted, you are dealing with fat and limescale, not urine scale.

In practice, the distinction is useful because it shows where to look. If the washbasin drains slowly, urine scale is not the cause. If the toilet or urinal drains slowly and smells of urine, it is the first suspect. The procedure in the pipe is similar for both: descale mechanically, flush out and check with the camera.

Preventing urine scale

Urine scale cannot be prevented entirely in hard water, but its growth can be slowed considerably. At home, it helps to clean the toilet bowl regularly with an acidic cleaner before thick rings form, and to flush rarely used toilets now and then. If you keep the deposit thin, you never have to laboriously remove it.

In commercial premises, restaurants and schools, flushing is the most important tool. Urinals should be set so that enough water follows after use to dilute the urine and carry it away. Defective flushes and sensors should be repaired promptly. Waterless urinals need the care specified by the manufacturer. A fixed cleaning schedule for the urinal and toilet pipes, matched to how the building is used, also makes sense.

For pipes that keep becoming choked, a CCTV drain survey is worthwhile. It shows whether too shallow a gradient, a displacement or too small a diameter encourages the deposit, and provides the basis for a sensible cleaning interval. In this way, recurring emergency cleaning becomes predictable maintenance.

Practical example

A typical case from the commercial sector: in a restaurant in the canton of Zurich, the water in the row of urinals in the gents' toilet drains away only slowly, and the room smells strongly of urine despite daily cleaning. The bowls themselves are clean, so the problem lies deeper. The CCTV drain survey reveals a thick layer of urine scale in the shared connection pipe, significantly narrowing the cross-section. The team removes the crust with a suitable milling head, flushes the chunks out at high pressure and then checks the pipe again with the camera. Finally, the business receives the footage and a recommendation to have the pipe cleaned preventively at fixed intervals in future, outside opening hours.

Further reading in our guides

Urine scale: frequently asked questions

How do I remove heavy urine scale in the toilet?+

Lower the water level in the bowl, apply vinegar essence or citric acid and leave it to act overnight. Then remove the dissolved deposit with a brush or plastic scraper and repeat the process if necessary. Steel wool and blades scratch the glaze and are off-limits.

What dissolves urine scale best?+

Because urine scale consists mainly of limescale and phosphate compounds, acids dissolve it: vinegar, vinegar essence, citric acid or acidic toilet cleaners. A long contact time is decisive. In the pipe, however, acids hardly work; there the urine scale is milled away mechanically.

Can urine scale block a toilet?+

Yes. In the connection pipe and the soil stack, urine scale gradually narrows the cross-section. Paper and solids get caught on the rough crust until the pipe is blocked. Typical are blockages that quickly return after being cleared.

Does drain cleaner help against urine scale in the pipe?+

Hardly. Chemical drain cleaners reach thick crusts only briefly and diluted, do not dissolve them completely and can attack seals and older pipes. Urine scale in the pipe is removed with a milling head, chain flail or rotating high-pressure nozzle.

Why does it smell of urine even though the bowl is clean?+

Urine scale is often lodged in the trap or the pipe. The porous crust stores urine residues and bacteria and constantly gives off odour. A dried-out water seal trap can also be the cause. A CCTV drain survey shows what is going on in the pipe.

How often should urinal pipes be cleaned?+

That depends on use, flush volume and water hardness. Heavily used facilities in restaurants, schools or public toilets need considerably more frequent cleaning than a private guest toilet. A CCTV drain survey after the first descaling helps to determine the right interval.

How much does it cost to remove urine scale from the pipe?+

Karo charges by time and effort: CHF 160 per hour plus CHF 60 call-out fee, excl. VAT. A surcharge from CHF 50 is added for the CCTV drain survey. How long the work takes depends on the length, diameter and thickness of the crust.

Urine scale in your region?

We are there for you across German-speaking Switzerland – fast, clean, with a 24/7 emergency service.