What is a separate sewer system?
Alongside the combined system, the separate system is the second basic principle of urban drainage. Instead of one shared sewer there are two: the foul sewer for wastewater from households and businesses, and the rainwater sewer for rainwater from roofs, yards and roads.
This separation continues on the property. The underground drains for foul water and rainwater run separately, have their own inspection chambers and their own connections to the respective public sewer. In newer neighbourhoods in Switzerland the separate system is now the rule; in older areas it is often introduced step by step, as provided for in the general drainage plan (GEP, Genereller Entwässerungsplan).
Advantages of the separate system
The biggest advantage is that it relieves the wastewater treatment plant. Because no rainwater enters the foul sewer, the volume stays relatively constant and the treatment plant can work efficiently. At the same time, there is no need for the overflows through which diluted wastewater enters watercourses in a combined system during heavy rain.
The system also has advantages for properties: the foul sewer fills up less quickly during thunderstorms, which reduces the risk of backflow. Clean rainwater can also be infiltrated or retained close to where it falls, as the Water Protection Act aims for.
Disadvantages and challenges
A separate system needs two pipe networks, which makes construction and maintenance more complex. On every property, two pipe runs have to be planned, built and looked after. In narrow streets and existing neighbourhoods, retrofitting is correspondingly costly.
The biggest weak point is misconnections. If a foul water drain is connected to the rainwater pipe, untreated wastewater flows directly into a stream or lake. Conversely, if a roof is connected to the foul sewer, the system loses part of its benefit. In addition, polluted road water may need treatment before it enters a watercourse, depending on how heavily it is polluted.
Finding and correcting misconnections
Misconnections usually arise during conversions: a new laundry room, an additional WC in the basement or a garage drain is connected to the nearest pipe without checking which one it is. This cannot be seen from the outside, and the fault often goes undetected for years.
To check, the pipes are surveyed with a camera and their route traced with a locating sonde. Dye tests show in which manhole the water from a particular drain arrives, and a smoke test reveals hidden connections. Many municipalities carry out systematic checks as part of the GEP and require misconnections to be corrected.
Maintenance in a separate system
Both pipes need care, but for different reasons. In the foul water pipe, grease, paper and solids build up. In the rainwater pipe, it is sand, leaves and roots, which are often underestimated because it is thought of as a ‘clean’ pipe.
High-pressure drain cleaning followed by a camera inspection of both runs is therefore part of regular maintenance. At the same time, it can be checked whether the pipes are watertight. Leaking foul water pipes endanger soil and groundwater, while leaking rainwater pipes take in infiltration water.
When a single-family home in Rapperswil-Jona was being sold, the buyers asked for evidence of the condition of the drainage. The municipality is served by a separate system. Karo surveyed the foul water and rainwater pipes with a camera and carried out dye tests on all drains. This showed that the drain of a utility sink added later in the garage was connected to the rainwater pipe and, conversely, the garage roof water pipe discharged into the foul sewer – two misconnections. A plumber corrected the connections, and Karo documented the final state with images and a plan.
