The difference is simple: in the combined system, foul water and rainwater flow together in one sewer to the wastewater treatment plant. In the separate system there are two sewers: the foul water goes to the treatment plant, while unpolluted rainwater goes directly into a stream, river or lake or into the ground. Which system applies to your property is decided by the municipality in its general drainage plan, not by the owner.
For homeowners, property managers and caretakers, this is more than theory. The system determines what may be poured into a forecourt gully, how great the risk of backflow in the basement is and which conditions apply when you renovate. This article compares the two systems in a table, shows how to identify the system at your own house, how misconnections are found and what a changeover to the separate system will mean for you. We explain the individual terms in detail in the glossary under combined sewer system and separate sewer system.
Combined and separate systems compared
Both systems have the same goal: to carry wastewater safely away from built-up areas and to protect watercourses. However, they deal with rain differently. The main differences at a glance:
| Feature | Combined system | Separate system |
|---|---|---|
| Number of sewers | one shared sewer | two separate sewers |
| Foul water (kitchen, bathroom, toilet, business) | to the treatment plant (WWTP) | in the foul water sewer to the WWTP |
| Rainwater from roofs, yards and roads | together with the foul water to the WWTP | in the stormwater sewer, usually untreated, into a watercourse, or it soaks away |
| In heavy rain | overflow structures (combined sewer overflows, stormwater tanks) discharge diluted wastewater into watercourses | foul water sewer remains largely unaffected, no combined sewer overflow needed |
| Critical points | backflow during thunderstorms, pollutants that burden the WWTP | anything that gets into forecourt and roof gullies ends up straight in the stream |
| On the property | one underground drain, one connection | two pipe runs, usually with their own inspection chambers |
| Typical of | often older built-up areas and village centres | newer neighbourhoods, often also industrial and commercial areas |
| Typical fault | backflow protection missing or defective | misconnection to the wrong pipe |
Besides the two basic forms, there are hybrid forms. In its information sheet, the Environment Office of the canton of Zug describes a modified system, a combination of the two basic forms: foul water and rainwater from roads and yards are carried away together, while unpolluted rainwater from roofs and forecourts, as well as seepage and spring water, flows into its own rainwater sewer. Today, for both systems, unpolluted water should soak away on site wherever possible.
How does the combined system work?
In the combined system, all of a property's wastewater is brought together: the foul water from the kitchen, bathroom, toilet and laundry room and the stormwater from the roof, terrace and forecourt. One pipe, one house connection, one public combined sewer all the way to the wastewater treatment plant.
The problem is the rain. In dry weather the sewer carries little water; in a thunderstorm it carries many times that amount. To prevent the sewers from being overloaded and to avoid backflow damage to properties, overflow structures are built into the network. In heavy rain, combined sewer overflows and stormwater tanks discharge part of the diluted wastewater into watercourses. This is how both the information sheet of the canton of Zurich and that of the canton of Zug describe it.
For owners, this means that in a violent thunderstorm the sewer can fill up and the water pushes back through the house connection. Drains below the backflow level, i.e. floor drains in the basement, laundry rooms or underground car parks, therefore need working backflow protection or a lifting station. What to bear in mind is set out in the guide Backflow in the basement.
How does the separate system work?
In the separate system, each type of water gets its own route. The polluted wastewater flows in the foul water sewer to the WWTP. Rainwater from roofs, yards and roads, provided it is considered unpolluted, flows in the stormwater sewer to the nearest watercourse, mostly without any prior treatment. Where the ground allows, it soaks away directly on the property via an infiltration system.
It is precisely this «without treatment» that makes the separate system sensitive. The information sheets of the cantons of Zurich and Zug give typical examples: if a car is washed on the forecourt, the water laden with cleaning agents flows straight into the nearest stream. The same happens if someone tips leftover plant protection products or other liquids hazardous to water into the forecourt drainage gully. According to both information sheets, industrial and commercial areas are often drained by the separate system, which makes handling and storage areas particularly critical.
On the property, the separation continues: two underground drains, usually two inspection chambers and two connections to the public sewers. Both pipe runs need maintenance, including the supposedly clean stormwater pipe, in which sand, leaves and roots collect. The article Cleaning stormwater pipes shows how this is done.
Advantages and disadvantages at a glance
Neither system is fundamentally better. It depends on where a property is located and how the surfaces are used.
- Combined system, advantage: only one pipe per road and property, no possibility of mixing up two systems, and polluted road water reaches the treatment plant.
- Combined system, disadvantage: clean rainwater is needlessly sent to the WWTP, diluted wastewater is discharged into watercourses in heavy rain, and the risk of backflow for low-lying drains is higher.
- Separate system, advantage: the treatment plant receives a more even volume of water, clean rainwater stays in the natural cycle, and the foul water sewer does not fill up as quickly in thunderstorms.
- Separate system, disadvantage: double the construction and maintenance effort, and every misconnection or careless disposal in the forecourt gully hits the watercourse directly.
Which system does my house have? How to find out
Which areas of a municipality are drained by which system is set out in the general drainage plan (GEP). According to the cantonal information sheets, neighbourhood planning and ultimately the drainage of every individual property must follow its requirements. This is how to get a reliable answer for your property:
Step 1: Ask the building administration
The municipal building departments, or the municipal engineers they commission, can tell you on the basis of the GEP whether your area is served by the combined or the separate system. This is the authoritative source.
Step 2: Look at the property's drainage plan
A plan of the property drainage is submitted with the building application. It shows whether separate pipes for foul water and stormwater were planned. If it is missing from your own files, it is often held in the municipality's building archive.
Step 3: Count and open the manholes
Two inspection chambers next to each other, one with faeces and paper, one with leaves and sand, suggest separate pipes. A single manhole into which both wastewater and roof water flow points to a combined system.
Step 4: Follow the roof water
Do the rainwater downpipes lead into a soakaway, an infiltration system or a pipe of their own? Or do they end up in the same pipe run as the wastewater? After renovations, the plan does not always match reality.
Step 5: If in doubt, have it checked
A CCTV drain survey with pipe locating shows where each pipe actually leads. This is particularly useful before a purchase, a renovation or a request from the municipality.
Important: the municipality may still operate a combined system in the public sewer while the pipes on your property are already run separately. Some municipalities require this for new buildings so that a later switch is possible without major excavation. The two pipes are then only brought together shortly before the connection to the public sewer.
Finding misconnections: smoke test, camera and dye test
A misconnection is when a pipe is connected to the wrong sewer. In the separate system there are two variants: foul water in the stormwater pipe, in which case untreated wastewater flows into a watercourse, or rainwater in the foul water sewer, in which case clean water burdens the treatment plant. Misconnections usually arise during renovations, when a new laundry room, a toilet in the basement or a garage drain is connected to the nearest pipe. You cannot see this from the outside.
To find them, we combine several methods during leak detection and the CCTV drain survey:
- CCTV drain survey: the camera travels from the manhole through the pipe and shows every side connection. We document the findings to SN EN 13508-2 so that they are easy to follow for the municipality, property managers or buyers.
- Pipe locating: a sonde on the camera head is located from above. This allows you to mark on the surface where the pipe runs and where a connection joins it.
- Smoke test: non-toxic artificial smoke is blown into the pipe. If it rises from a rainwater downpipe even though it was blown into the foul water sewer, a misconnection has been found.
- Dye test: water with a dye is poured into a specific drain, and then we watch which manhole it arrives in. This is the most direct proof of which drain is connected to which pipe.
An example from our glossary shows what this looks like in practice: when a single-family home in Rapperswil-Jona, served at that point by the separate system, was being sold, the dye test showed that the drain of a utility sink retrofitted in the garage was connected to the stormwater pipe, and conversely the garage's roof water pipe discharged into the foul water sewer. Two misconnections at one house, both created during a renovation. A plumber connected them correctly, and the final state was documented with images and a plan.
Changeover to the separate system: what does it mean for owners?
Municipalities can gradually switch older areas from the combined to the separate system or require roof water to be taken off the sewer. The reason is given in both cantonal information sheets: clean rainwater, seepage water and spring water, known as infiltration water, needs no treatment, only causes costs at the WWTP and should not be removed from the natural water cycle. Whether and when your area will be switched is decided by the municipality through the GEP and its drainage regulations.
For owners, a changeover generally involves these steps:
Step 1: Survey of the existing system
First it must be clear which drains there are and where they connect. To establish this, the pipes are cleaned, surveyed with the camera and located. Without this basis, no one can plan which pipe needs to be reconnected.
Step 2: Assess the condition
The survey also shows whether the existing underground drain is still serviceable. If it is watertight and intact, it can often continue to be used as the foul water pipe, and only the stormwater needs a new route.
Step 3: New concept for the rainwater
The roof water is either soaked away, routed into a new stormwater connection or held back. What is permitted depends on the subsoil and the municipality's requirements.
Step 4: Construction work
Downpipes are reconnected, new pipes and manholes are built and connected to the correct sewer. Depending on the location, this involves excavation on the property.
Step 5: Testing and documentation
At the end, it is proven that every drain is connected to the correct sewer and that the new pipes are watertight, for example with a CCTV drain survey, a dye test and a leak-tightness test. The documentation belongs in the property's building records.
What a changeover costs cannot be stated as a flat figure. It depends on how many downpipes and drains need to be reconnected, how long the new pipes are, whether soakaway is possible and what condition the existing pipes are in. A reliable figure is only available after the survey of the existing system. For this initial assessment, we charge by time spent: CHF 160 per working hour and CHF 60 call-out, both excl. VAT, plus a supplement from CHF 50 for the CCTV drain survey.
At Karo, we take on the parts that relate to the pipe itself: drain cleaning before the survey, the camera inspection with locating, the leak-tightness test of the new pipes and, if required, a condition assessment as a basis for decisions. For excavation and new manholes, there are our civil works.
What to bear in mind in everyday life
- In the separate system, nothing but rainwater belongs in forecourt, roof or garage gullies: no cleaning water, no car-washing water, no leftover paint, oil or plant protection products.
- In the combined system, the same applies to substances that damage the treatment plant. According to the information sheets, a discharge of pollutants can kill off the biological stage of a WWTP.
- If you have drains below the backflow level in the combined system, have the backflow protection serviced regularly.
- If you are renovating, clarify which pipe a new drain will end up in before connecting it. A misconnection is easily avoided during construction and only found later with considerable effort.
- Tenants, caretakers and property managers should know which system the property is drained by. According to the cantonal information sheets, the person responsible can also face criminal and civil proceedings if a watercourse is polluted.
Sources
This article is based on the information sheet “Combined or separate system” (in German) of the Office for Waste, Water, Energy and Air (AWEL) of the canton of Zurich, Water Protection Division, May 2015, and on the information sheet “Combined and separate systems for wastewater – what does it mean?” (in German) of the Environment Office of the Building Department of the canton of Zug. Both are published as PDFs on the cantons' websites. Authoritative information for your property is provided by your municipality's building administration on the basis of the GEP.



