What is tracer gas?
Tracer gas (German: Tracergas, roughly «Spürgas») is a gas that is introduced into a pipe in order to make its leaking points visible or, more precisely, measurable. The term comes from the verb «to trace», meaning to track down. The gas itself does not repair anything; it serves exclusively as a marker that reaches the surface wherever the pipe has a hole, a crack or a leaking connection.
For leak detection on water and heating pipes, forming gas is used almost always in practice. This is a mixture of around 95 percent nitrogen and 5 percent hydrogen that is familiar from welding and is supplied in gas cylinders. The hydrogen content is the actual tracer gas; the nitrogen serves as the carrier gas. As an alternative, helium is used in individual cases; it is also very small and light, but considerably more expensive to obtain.
On the Karo Kanaltechnik service page, tracer gas leak detection with forming gas is listed as one of the location methods – for pressure pipes and hard-to-reach areas.
How does leak detection with forming gas work?
The principle is based on two properties of hydrogen: it is the lightest gas of all and consists of very small molecules. That is why it escapes even from very fine leaks through which water only escapes drop by drop or not visibly at all, and it travels upwards from the leak – through soil, gravel, paving, asphalt joints, screed and floor coverings.
At the surface, the technician follows the route of the pipe with a hydrogen detector. Its sensor already reacts to very low concentrations in the ppm range, i.e. to a few millionths of a part in the air. Where the reading peaks, the escape point is usually directly below or very close by. Under sealed surfaces, small probe holes are sometimes drilled so that the gas can find its way to the measuring device.
Forming gas with this low hydrogen content is regarded as non-flammable, is non-toxic and leaves no residues in the pipe. It dissipates by itself after the measurement. For drinking water pipes, this is an important point: nothing is introduced that could later come out of the tap.
Where is tracer gas used?
The classic area of application is pressure pipes that can be sealed and filled with gas. These include drinking water house connections between the water meter and the road, cold and hot water pipes in the building, heating pipes and above all underfloor heating, whose pipes lie in the screed. Pipes to garden connections, pools or outbuildings can also be tested in this way.
Tracer gas is particularly valuable for plastic pipes made of PE, PEX or composite pipe. Plastic transmits the noise of a leak poorly, so acoustic location often does not deliver a clear result there. The same applies to very small leaks with little pressure loss that barely make a noise, and to pipes under thick coverings in which the noise is muffled.
With gravity wastewater pipes, on the other hand, tracer gas is rarely the first choice. There, the CCTV drain survey, the leak-tightness test in accordance with SN EN 1610 and the smoke test are the usual tools, because a gravity pipe with many connections can only be sealed gas-tight with considerable effort. With wastewater pressure pipes, for example downstream of a lifting station, a gas test can be useful, however.
Tracer gas leak detection step by step
It starts with narrowing down the problem: which pipe run is losing water or pressure? With heating, this is often indicated by falling system pressure; with drinking water, by a water meter that keeps registering consumption even when the taps are closed. By shutting off individual runs, the affected section is identified. At the same time, the route of the pipe must be known – from plans or through prior pipe locating.
The affected section is then shut off and largely drained so that the gas does not have to work against a standing column of water. The forming gas is fed in from the cylinder via a pressure reducer, and the pipe is put under a moderate test pressure. Then some patience is needed: depending on the cover depth, type of ground and size of the leak, it takes a certain time for the gas to arrive measurably at the surface.
The technician then systematically scans the area along the pipe route, indoors with a bell probe on the floor, outdoors also with a probe rod in drill holes. The spot with the highest reading is marked and documented. After the repair, the pipe is refilled, bled in the case of heating systems, and checked with a pressure test to confirm that it is now watertight.
Advantages of the tracer gas method
The biggest advantage is sensitivity. Because hydrogen is so small and the detector picks up even slight traces, the method also finds hairline cracks, porous soldered joints and leaking press fittings that lose only a little water and therefore go unnoticed for a long time. It is precisely these creeping leaks that often do the greatest damage to screed, insulation and masonry over months.
A second advantage is independence from the pipe material. Whether copper, galvanised steel, PE or composite pipe – the gas escapes wherever the pipe is leaking. The method also works when ambient noise such as traffic, pumps or ventilation systems would interfere with an acoustic measurement.
Finally, the method is non-destructive: nothing is broken open for the measurement itself. Only the one spot where the leak has been proven is opened up. This keeps the damage to tiles, parquet or asphalt to a minimum and, with the cause and location, provides the documentation for the claim to the insurer.
Limitations and typical pitfalls
Tracer gas gives a reading where the gas reaches the surface – and that is not always exactly above the leak. Dense layers such as bitumen membranes, waterproofing sheets, concrete slabs or loamy, wet ground can deflect the gas sideways. It can travel some distance along protective pipe sleeves, insulation or empty conduits and emerge at a joint or a wall opening.
Outdoors, wind dilutes the gas at the surface, and with very deep pipes the journey upwards takes a long time. In addition, it must be possible to shut off and drain the pipe, which means a short interruption for a heating system in winter or for a drinking water connection. And where several leaks are present at the same time, the readings overlap.
That is why a single deflection of the detector is not yet a finding. Experienced technicians check the result for plausibility: they compare several measuring points, take the floor build-up and the route of the pipe into account and, if necessary, call in a second method.
Tracer gas in combination with acoustics and thermography
In practice, tracer gas is rarely the only tool. With metal pipes under pressure, acoustic location with a ground microphone or correlation measurement often quickly provides an initial narrowing down, because the escaping water creates an audible noise. Where this noise is absent or ambiguous, tracer gas provides clarity.
Thermography complements both with warm pipes: a thermal imaging camera makes the route of underfloor heating and hot water pipes visible and shows warm patches where warm water escapes. This establishes the search area, and the tracer gas then confirms the exact spot. For pressure pipes, Karo Kanaltechnik uses these three methods – acoustics, tracer gas and thermography – and combines them depending on the pipe.
After the location work, Karo clients receive a report with the position of the leak in the site plan of the method used and a recommendation for the most economical repair, trenchless or conventional. If the damage affects a wastewater pipe, a camera survey usually follows, and the pipe can often be repaired without digging, for example with a patch liner.
When should you arrange a tracer gas survey?
The trigger is almost always a loss of water without a visible cause: the heating has to be topped up regularly, the water meter keeps registering consumption at night, the water bill rises, damp patches appear in the basement or on the wall, parquet bulges or a spot in the garden stays permanently wet. The earlier the location is carried out, the smaller the consequential damage from damp penetration and mould.
Before the location work, it is worth having plans of the property, information on the pipe material and – if available – notes on the pressure history to hand. This shortens the narrowing-down process. The costs depend on the effort involved and the method used; Karo prepares a quote for this on request.
A typical case in a single-family home in the Winterthur region: the pressure of the underfloor heating drops every few weeks, and there is no visible moisture. The plastic heating pipes lie in the screed under a tiled floor, so an acoustic measurement does not pick up a clear noise. First, the thermal imaging camera is used to make the route of the heating circuits visible, and the suspect circuit is shut off at the manifold. This circuit is then drained and filled with forming gas. With the bell probe, the highest hydrogen reading shows up in a tile joint in the corridor. Only this one spot is opened, the pipe is repaired, and the circuit is refilled, bled and checked for leak-tightness with a pressure test.
