What is a vacuum excavator?
A vacuum excavator is a lorry with a high-performance blower, a large debris container and a movable suction boom with a thick suction hose hanging from its end. The blower generates a very strong air stream. Everything that comes in front of the hose opening – loose earth, gravel, sand, building rubble, leaves or sludge – is drawn in and ends up in the container on the vehicle.
The name is somewhat misleading: a vacuum excavator has no shovel and no bucket. It «excavates» in a figurative sense, by sucking up material. That is why people also speak of suction excavation or vacuum excavation. It is often operated by one person directly at the pit, who guides the hose and controls the suction boom and blower by remote control. This means the operator can see at all times what is being exposed.
How suction excavation works
Solid ground cannot simply be sucked up. It is first loosened – depending on the soil, with a compressed-air lance, with a water jet or by hand with a spade. The operator then guides the suction hose over the loosened spot. The air stream carries the material with it; in the container, the air slows down, the material drops out and the cleaned air leaves the vehicle via filters.
In this way, a clean, tightly confined pit is created layer by layer. Because the hose is flexible and the suction boom can swing out a long way, the vehicle does not have to stand directly next to the pit. A vacuum excavator can therefore also work where an excavator cannot reach: between the house wall and the garden wall, under a canopy, next to the roots of a tree or in a light well. When the container is full, the vehicle tips the excavated material at an interim storage site or a disposal point.
Exposing pipes gently with minimal digging
The most important strength of the vacuum excavator is that it protects whatever lies in the ground. Besides the wastewater pipes, the ground beneath a property often contains water, gas and electricity lines, telecommunications cables and district heating pipes. An excavator bucket can damage such a line in an instant – with expensive consequences and, in the case of a gas pipe, dangerous ones. The air stream of the vacuum excavator, on the other hand, only carries loose material; pipes and cables remain intact in place.
Then there is the small scale of the intervention. Instead of digging a long trench, a trial slot or a single hole above the spot where work needs to be done is often sufficient. The area around the pit stays clean, because no excavated material is piled up next to it. Paving, lawn and planting only need to be opened up and restored over a small area. Specialists therefore speak of minimal-dig working: it cannot be done entirely without excavation, but the trench is as small as possible.
Use in civil works and pipe locating
In drainage technology, the vacuum excavator comes into play mainly when a pipe needs to be openly accessible at a specific point: in the event of a pipe collapse at the house connection, a collapsed pipe section that a CIPP liner can no longer bridge, when connecting a new pipe to an existing one or when exposing a covered-over inspection chamber. Such work is part of the civil works in drain rehabilitation.
The order is decisive here. First, the pipe is examined from the inside: in the CCTV drain survey, the camera shows exactly where the damage is, and a locating sonde on the camera head reveals the position and depth of the pipe at the surface. This spot is marked. Only then is digging carried out – and only there. Pipe locating and suction excavation thus complement each other: locating says where to dig, and the vacuum excavator ensures that nothing gets damaged in the process.
Before any excavation, it is also essential to check the utility plans of the municipality and the utility companies. They show which third-party pipes and cables may be located nearby. The more lines there are in a confined space, the more worthwhile it is to expose them by suction rather than with an excavator bucket.
Vacuum excavator, vacuum tanker and jetting vehicle: the difference
The terms are often confused because all three vehicles suck something up. A jetting vehicle, also called a vacuum tanker or jet-vac tanker, is built for drain cleaning: it flushes pipes with high-pressure water, sucks sludge, wastewater and loosened deposits out of manholes, gullies and pits, and works with a vacuum pump that creates negative pressure in the tank. Its element is liquids and sludge.
The vacuum excavator, by contrast, is designed for dry and solid material. Instead of a vacuum pump that mainly sucks in liquids, it works with a high-performance blower that moves a very large volume of air and thus also carries stones, gravel and clods of earth with it. It cannot flush a sewer, and it is the wrong device for cleaning an underground drain. Conversely, a jetting tanker is not made for excavating soil. On a construction site, both can work side by side: the vacuum excavator exposes the pipe, and the jetting vehicle cleans it before the camera goes in.
What determines the cost of a vacuum excavator
Vacuum excavators are generally not offered as a bare machine, but with a driver and operator at an hourly rate, because the vehicle requires experience in handling the hose, blower and remote control. Anyone searching for «hire vacuum excavator» therefore usually ends up with a job including personnel. The costs typically consist of several parts: the time on site, the outward and return journey, any minimum job times and the disposal of the extracted material.
How long a job takes depends mainly on the soil. Loose gravel and sand can be sucked up quickly; heavy, loamy or stony soil must first be laboriously loosened. Access also plays a role: if the vehicle can drive close to the pit, the work goes faster than with long hose runs. Per hour, a vacuum excavator is generally more expensive than a mini excavator. It can nevertheless be worthwhile, because less surface area has to be torn up, less digging has to be done by hand and less needs to be restored, and the risk of damaging a pipe is reduced. Reliable prices are therefore only available after a site visit and as a quote in which suction excavation is shown as a separate item.
Limitations of the vacuum excavator
Not every excavation is a job for the vacuum excavator. For long pipe sections that have to be completely replaced, conventional open-cut construction with an excavator is usually more economical. Large stones and lumps of concrete do not fit through the hose and have to be removed by hand or with other equipment. Frozen ground, heavily compacted base layers and asphalt or concrete surfacing are broken up first.
Then there is the weight and size of the vehicle. A vacuum excavator is a heavy lorry; garden paths, narrow courtyard driveways or underground car park roofs are not always designed for it. And the blower is loud during operation. In residential areas, the job therefore has to be carefully scheduled. For small excavations at easily accessible spots, the spade sometimes remains the simplest solution.
What property owners should look out for
Anyone who needs to have a pipe exposed on their property should first know exactly where to dig. A camera survey with locating is the basis for this: it prevents searching on suspicion and opening up an unnecessarily large area. The property's drainage plan and the utility plans help to avoid surprises in the ground.
Then it is worth asking which method is suitable: if the damage can be repaired from the inside without digging, for example with a patch liner or a CIPP liner, no pit is needed at all. If excavation is necessary, the location, density of lines, soil and access determine whether a vacuum excavator, a mini excavator or hand digging makes the most sense. After the repair, a leak-tightness test is part of the job – for newly laid pipes in accordance with SN EN 1610 – before the pit is backfilled and the surface is properly restored.
A typical case from the Winterthur area: in an apartment building, wastewater backs up in the basement. The CCTV drain survey reveals a pipe collapse in the underground drain just before the house connection – directly under the paved forecourt, under which, according to the utility plan, gas and electricity lines also run. The damaged spot is marked on the surface with the locating sonde. Instead of tearing up the forecourt over a wide area, a vacuum excavator exposes only a small hole exactly above the break; the third-party lines remain untouched. The defective pipe section is replaced, the pipe is tested for leak-tightness, the pit is backfilled and the paving is relaid over a small area.
