What is a vitrified clay pipe?
Vitrified clay is a ceramic material: clay and fireclay grog are shaped, dried and fired at very high temperatures until the ceramic body sinters into a dense mass. The result is a hard, barely porous material that neither rusts nor rots. To help wastewater flow away well and to reduce the build-up of dirt, the pipes are usually glazed inside and out – on old pipes you can recognise this by the shiny, brownish surface.
In everyday language, people also speak of clay pipes or clay drains. In drainage technology, this always means the same thing: a rigid ceramic pipe for foul water or rainwater that runs by gravity towards the sewer. Today, the standard SN EN 295 sets out requirements and tests for vitrified clay pipes and their joints in drains and sewers.
Vitrified clay is not a material of the past. Modern vitrified clay pipes with factory-fitted seals are still used for sewers, especially where the wastewater is chemically aggressive. Anyone who speaks of «old clay pipes» therefore primarily means the jointing technology of the time – not the material as such.
Properties: what vitrified clay does well – and what it does not
The greatest strength of vitrified clay is its resistance. Acids, alkalis and most chemicals found in domestic or commercial wastewater hardly attack the glazed surface. Abrasion from sand and gravel that enters the pipe with rainwater also leaves few traces. Unlike concrete, vitrified clay hardly suffers from corrosion caused by sulphur compounds from the wastewater.
The downside is brittleness. Vitrified clay has very high compressive strength, but it is not elastic. If the bedding material gives way, the ground subsides or too high a load acts from above, the pipe cannot deform – it cracks or breaks. Vibrations from construction work, heavy vehicles over a shallow pipe or roots widening an existing crack also take their toll on the material.
Then there is the design: older vitrified clay pipes come in short lengths. A pipe run therefore consists of many individual pipe sections and correspondingly many joints. Each of these connections is a potential weak point where the pipe can shift, start leaking or let roots in.
Prevalence in older properties
In Swiss properties built before around 1970, underground drains and house connections made of vitrified clay are often found in the ground, frequently alongside concrete or asbestos cement pipes. Inside such houses, cast iron pipes are more common. Later, plastic pipes became increasingly widespread, but vitrified clay remained in use, above all for underground drains and sewer pipes.
Many houses have since been converted, extended upwards or partially renovated. That is why a single pipe run often contains several materials one after the other: a new plastic pipe in the basement that turns into an old vitrified clay underground drain at the outer wall, followed perhaps by a concrete house connection. The transitions between the materials are also typical points of damage.
Whether vitrified clay is in the ground cannot be said with certainty from the outside. Old drainage plans give clues, but are often incomplete. A CCTV drain survey brings certainty: the camera image shows the pipe material, the nominal diameter and the spacing of the joints, and the report records the material for each section.
Typical damage patterns on CCTV
The most common finding in old vitrified clay pipes is the displaced joint. In the past, the pipes were pushed into each other and sealed with tarred hemp rope and mortar. Over the decades, these seals become brittle, the pipe sections settle or shift against each other, and a step forms at the joint. Paper, grease and solids get caught on it, and the pipe repeatedly becomes blocked at the same spot.
Fine roots penetrate through leaking joints. They are searching for moisture and nutrients, grow into dense root masses inside the pipe and force the joint further open over time. Root ingress is therefore particularly common in vitrified clay pipes in gardens with trees and shrubs.
Because of their brittleness, old vitrified clay pipes also show longitudinal and circumferential cracks. If several cracks meet, the pipe wall breaks up into individual fragments – this is known as fragmentation (a shattered pipe). The fragments are often only held together by the surrounding soil; in the worst case, the pipe collapses. Further findings include chipped glaze, encrustation, leaking or poorly connected lateral connections and groundwater entering as infiltration water.
During the CCTV drain survey, this damage is coded in accordance with SN EN 13508-2 and documented with its location and extent. This produces a report showing whether only individual spots are damaged or whether the entire pipe has reached the end of its service life. This distinction is the basis for every rehabilitation decision.
Cleaning vitrified clay pipes
Vitrified clay pipes can be cleaned well as long as the technique is adapted to their condition. Chemical-free high-pressure water jetting loosens deposits, grease and sand without attacking the glazed surface. With intact pipes, strong pressure can be used; Karo uses high pressure of up to 200 bar, but chooses the pressure and nozzle according to the pipe and the findings.
Caution is needed with pipes that already show cracks or fragmentation. Too hard a water jet or a chain flail can dislodge loose fragments and make the damage worse. That is why a camera survey before or immediately after cleaning is part of the job with older vitrified clay pipes. Roots that have grown in are removed with the robotic cutter – this restores the free cross-section, but does not eliminate the leaking joint through which they entered.
Rehabilitation: CIPP liners and patch liners instead of digging
For most damage to vitrified clay pipes, trenchless rehabilitation is the first choice. With a CIPP liner (cured-in-place pipe), a resin-impregnated tube is pulled into the cleaned old pipe, pressed against the pipe wall and cured. This creates a new, seamless pipe within the old one. The many joints, the weak point of vitrified clay, are thus bridged along the entire length, and roots can no longer find a way in.
If only individual spots are damaged – for example a displaced joint or a local crack – a patch liner (short liner), also known as a Pointliner, is often sufficient. It is placed exactly at the damaged spot and seals it over a short length. This is generally quicker and cheaper than a liner along the entire pipe run. Lateral connections are reopened with the robotic cutter after lining and, if necessary, sealed with a top-hat profile.
The prerequisite for both methods is that the old pipe still holds its shape and can support the liner. Even fragmentation can sometimes still be lined, as long as the fragments stay in position and the cross-section is preserved. Karo provides a warranty of up to 10 years on rehabilitation work. After rehabilitation, a further camera survey documents the work carried out; if required, a leak-tightness test in accordance with SN EN 1610 proves that the pipe is watertight.
When replacement is necessary
Not every vitrified clay pipe can be saved without digging. If the pipe has collapsed, parts of the pipe wall are missing or the cross-section is so badly deformed that a liner can no longer fit tightly, the section must be replaced. The same applies if the gradient is no longer correct: if the pipe has sagged into a dip, water stands there, and a liner would simply reproduce the dip.
There are two ways to replace it. In open-cut construction, the pipe is exposed and the old pipe is replaced with a new one – sensible for short sections, for incorrect gradients or when digging is taking place anyway, for example for a new driveway. With pipe bursting, the brittle vitrified clay is broken up in the ground and a new pipe is pulled in at the same time; this only requires launch and reception pits.
Which route is right is decided by the camera image together with the space available, the position of the pipe and the requirements of the municipality. In many cases, a combination makes sense: the collapsed section is replaced, and the rest of the vitrified clay pipe is rehabilitated without digging.
A typical case from our service area: in an apartment building from the 1950s in the Zurich area, the basement floor drain backs up every few months. Jetting only solves the problem for a short time each time. The CCTV drain survey reveals a vitrified clay underground drain with several displaced joints, root ingress at two points and a section with longitudinal cracks just before the house connection. The roots are cut out, the pipe is cleaned and the entire length is rehabilitated with a CIPP liner. This bridges all the joints without digging up the garden. The final survey documents the rehabilitated condition for the owners and the property management company.
